correlational
Analysis v1
13
Pro
0
Against

Obese mice don’t get as excited (in brain terms) when they see food—but when they lose weight, this brain response comes back, unlike their response to fat or hormones.

Scientific Claim

In mice, diet-induced obesity is associated with a reversible blunting of AgRP neuron inhibition in response to sensory food cues (e.g., sight/smell of food), which normalizes after weight loss, unlike responses to gut-derived signals.

Original Statement

Diet-induced obesity reversibly attenuates the AgRP neuron inhibition in response to food presentation... Subsequent weight loss restores the responsiveness of AgRP neurons to exterosensory cues...

Evidence Quality Assessment

Claim Status

overstated

Study Design Support

Design supports claim

Appropriate Language Strength

association

Can only show association/correlation

Assessment Explanation

The study shows association between obesity and reversible sensory blunting, but causal language ('attenuates', 'restores') overstates the evidence. Design cannot prove causation.

More Accurate Statement

In mice, diet-induced obesity is associated with a reversible blunting of AgRP neuron inhibition in response to sensory food cues, which normalizes after weight loss, unlike responses to gut-derived signals.

Evidence from Studies

Supporting (1)

13

When mice get fat from eating fatty food, their brain stops reacting as strongly to the sight or smell of food — but when they lose weight, that reaction comes back. However, their brain still doesn’t respond well to signals from the gut, even after losing weight.

Contradicting (0)

0
No contradicting evidence found