assertion
Analysis v1
0
Pro
45
Against

When people skip breakfast, they end up eating most of their food at night, which makes their body worse at handling sugar and hurts their sleep.

Scientific Claim

Delayed meal timing, particularly consumption of the majority of daily calories in the evening, impairs glucose tolerance and disrupts sleep quality.

Original Statement

And a lot of times when people skip breakfast, their meals get pushed into the evening time where they're eating a lot of meals later in the day or at least the bulk of their calories later in the day. This can make it so that you have metabolic slowdown and chronic caloric restriction. This can lead to impaired glucose tolerance. It leads to impaired sleep.

Context Details

Domain

nutrition

Population

human

Subject

Delayed meal timing with majority of daily calories consumed in the evening

Action

impairs

Target

glucose tolerance and disrupts sleep quality

Intervention Details

Type: diet
Duration: chronic

Evidence from Studies

3 pending
3 studies are still being processed and not included in the score yet.

Supporting (2)

0
Why this evidence?

When people ate dinner at 10 PM instead of 6 PM, their blood sugar spiked higher and stayed up longer — proving eating late makes your body worse at handling sugar.

Technical explanation

This study directly compares late eating (22:00) vs. early eating (18:00) and finds worse glucose and insulin responses after late meals, explicitly testing the assertion’s core claim and attributing it to circadian misalignment — not just sleep timing.

Why this evidence?

When pregnant women with diabetes eat later at night, their blood sugar stays high overnight, which makes it harder for their bodies to stay healthy — this shows eating late is bad for blood sugar control.

Technical explanation

This study directly compares early vs. late meal timing in pregnant women with GDM and finds that later eating leads to higher overnight glucose levels, directly supporting the assertion that delayed meal timing impairs glucose tolerance. It also implies sleep disruption due to metabolic stress, though sleep quality is not directly measured.

Contradicting (2)

45

This study says skipping breakfast is bad for blood sugar, but it doesn’t say anything about eating late at night or how that affects sleep or glucose tolerance.

Why this evidence?

People who ate all their meals between noon and 8 PM didn’t sleep worse than others — so eating late doesn’t necessarily ruin your sleep.

Technical explanation

This study tests time-restricted eating with meals confined to 12:00–8:00 PM (i.e., late eating window) and finds no negative effect on sleep quality, directly contradicting the assertion that evening calorie consumption disrupts sleep.