comparison
Analysis v1
46
Pro
33
Against

When a muscle crosses two joints, stretching it at one joint makes it longer overall, which can make it grow more when you exercise it.

Scientific Claim

Exercises that position biarticulate muscles at longer lengths (via joint angle manipulation) produce greater hypertrophy in those biarticulate muscle heads compared to exercises that place them at shorter lengths.

Original Statement

Bioticular muscles cross over two joints. And here are the main biotic muscles most of us care about. Different exercises can involve different joint positions such that some exercises are going to train biotic muscles at a longer muscle length than others. Take a seated leg curl and a lying leg curl. Both of these exercises have us flex our knees. However, the seated leg curl has our hip joint flexed at approximately 90° while the lying leg curl involves virtually no hip flexion. Three of the four hamstring heads are biotic and are consequently lengthened more with hip flexion. Thus, seated leg curls train the biotic hamstring muscles at a longer muscle length.

Context Details

Domain

exercise

Population

human

Subject

training of biarticulate muscles via joint positioning that elongates them

Action

produces

Target

greater hypertrophy in biarticulate muscle heads compared to shorter-length conditions

Intervention Details

Type: exercise
Dosage: Multiple sets to failure, 8–12 reps, 8–12 weeks
Duration: 8–12 weeks

Evidence from Studies

Supporting (1)

46

This study found that when muscles are stretched more during exercise (like bending your knee more), they work harder — and working harder like this is how muscles grow bigger over time. So even though it didn’t measure muscle growth directly, it shows the right conditions for it.

Contradicting (1)

33

The study found that doing exercises that stretch muscles more doesn’t make those muscles grow bigger than exercises that keep them more relaxed — so stretching muscles more during workouts doesn’t give you extra muscle growth.