Strong Support

In older men, doing resistance exercises such as weightlifting increased muscle strength, muscle size, and lean tissue in the thighs, even without taking HMB supplements, indicating that the exercise itself was the main factor driving these changes.

60
Pro
0
Against

Evidence from Studies

Supporting (1)

60

Community contributions welcome

The study found that older men got stronger and built more muscle just from doing weight training—even without taking any special supplement. The supplement didn’t make them any stronger or thicker than those who didn’t take it, so the exercise itself was the real hero.

Contradicting (0)

0

Community contributions welcome

No contradicting evidence found

Gold Standard Evidence Needed

According to GRADE and EBM methodology, here is what ideal scientific evidence would look like to definitively prove or disprove this specific claim, ordered from strongest to weakest evidence.

Science Topic

Does resistance training improve muscle strength and thickness in older men without HMB supplements?

Supported
Resistance Training in Older Men

We analyzed the available evidence and found that resistance training appears to improve muscle strength and thickness in older men, even without HMB supplements. Both studies we reviewed showed measurable gains in muscle size, strength, and lean tissue in the thighs after resistance exercises like weightlifting, with no mention of HMB being needed for these changes [1][2]. The evidence we’ve reviewed includes 120 separate assertions, all supporting this idea, with none contradicting it. In one set of findings, older men who performed resistance exercises saw increases in muscle strength and thigh muscle size without any HMB supplementation, suggesting the training itself played the central role [1]. In another, healthy men over 65 who trained without HMB supplements still gained muscle strength and thickness after just six weeks [2]. These results indicate that the physical stimulus from lifting weights or similar activities may be enough to trigger these adaptations, even in older age. We don’t know if these changes continue long-term or how they compare to other types of training, but what we’ve found so far suggests that resistance training alone can lead to meaningful improvements in muscle health for older men. No study we reviewed showed a lack of benefit when HMB was omitted. For older men looking to stay strong and maintain muscle, this means that simply doing regular weight-based exercises — even without special supplements — may be enough to help preserve or build muscle over time.

2 items of evidenceView full answer