assertion
Analysis v1
0
Pro
24
Against

Nothing you put on your face — even oil — clogs your pores and causes acne, contrary to what many skincare labels claim.

Scientific Claim

The concept of comedogenicity as applied to modern topical skincare products is largely invalid; the vast majority of commercially available oils and emollients, including petrolatum and olive oil, do not induce follicular occlusion or acne formation in human skin.

Original Statement

So comedogenicity, which it refers to a product's ability to clog pores and therefore, “clog pores”, and therefore stimulate the occurrence of acne. So that's a really misunderstood topic. Like, it's probably one of the worst words ever in my field. It's really a research term, and that's really where it comes from. So it's not really, really it's like real life. Only a few things are comedogenic, per, as per, like the very complicated research that went into this like 50 years ago. You know, things like, i don’ know, coal, tar infused stuff. Almost nothing that's available on the market today, I'm going to say almost nothing, I don't know everything, but almost nothing is comedogenic at all. Whether it's Vaseline, Vaseline’s certainly not comedogenic. Vaseline, olive oil based products, oily products, oils. You know, none of these products are comedogenic, and they never have been and they never will be. So Vaseline is actually used as a negative control for comedogenesy testing. Vaseline is because we know it does not cause clogged pores.

Context Details

Domain

dermatology

Population

human

Subject

Modern topical oils and emollients

Action

do not induce

Target

comedogenesis or acne formation

Intervention Details

Type: lifestyle
Dosage: unspecified
Duration: chronic

Evidence from Studies

Supporting (0)

0
No supporting evidence found

Contradicting (1)

24
24

A human model for assessing comedogenic substances.

Cross-Sectional Study
Human
1982 Nov

This study found that some oils and ingredients that clog rabbit ears also clog human pores, meaning the idea that certain ingredients cause acne isn’t nonsense — it actually works in people too.