View

The Study

Increased Consumption of Dairy Foods and Protein during Diet- and Exercise-Induced Weight Loss Promotes Fat Mass Loss and Lean Mass Gain in Overweight and Obese Premenopausal Women

In simple terms

This study didn't just watch people eat — it gave different groups different diets and exercise plans to see what happened. Because people were randomly assigned, we can guess that the diet probably caused the changes in body fat and muscle — but we can't be 100% sure because people knew what they were eating.

45%

Analysis score

45/ 45

Maximum 45 for a randomized controlled trial.

Where the score came from

Reporting0
Methodology65
Publication100
Statistical54
Study type (basis of the score)
Randomized Controlled Trial
Level 1b - Individual RCT
What’s the bottom line?

When women tried to lose weight by eating less and exercising, those who ate more protein and drank more milk lost more belly fat and even gained muscle, while others just lost weight without gaining muscle.

Where does this study sit?

Reviews of RCTs (Meta-analyses)

Max 100

Randomized Trials

Max 90

Reviews of Cohort Studies

Max 85

Cohort Studies

Max 72

Reviews of Case-Control Studies

Max 63

Case-Control Studies

Max 58

Cross-Sectional & Case Series

Max 50

Expert Opinion

Max 5
StrongerWeaker
Randomized Trials
Level 1b
45

45 / 100

Quality score

Participants are randomly assigned to treatment or control groups, minimizing bias. The gold standard for testing whether an intervention causes an effect.

Can establish causation

Save studies & get personalized insights

Create a free account to save this study, track new evidence as it comes in, and get breakdowns of studies in the topics you care about.

Key takeaways

Summary

Based on the study abstract and findings.

  1. 1Yes — gaining muscle while losing fat means better metabolism, strength, and long-term weight control, even if the scale doesn't change.
  2. 2Women who ate 30% protein and 15% dairy protein gained 0.7 kg of muscle and lost more belly fat than those eating less protein or dairy, even though everyone lost the same total weight (about 4.3 kg).

Score breakdown, methodology, conflicts of interest, evidence analysis & raw study data

Publication

Journal

The Journal of Nutrition

Year

2011

Authors

A. Josse, Stephanie A. Atkinson, M. Tarnopolsky, Stuart M Phillips

Open Access
227 citations
Analysis v5

Related Content

Claims (7)

Assertion

Consuming more protein results in greater gains in muscle mass and strength, and these gains are larger than the biological effects caused by activation of the mTOR pathway.

Causal
Read analysis
Assertion

In overweight premenopausal women losing weight, the amount of fat around the torso measured by DXA scan accurately reflects the reduction in deep abdominal fat, making DXA a valid alternative to MRI for measuring this change.

Correlational
Read analysis
Assertion

Among overweight and obese premenopausal women, a diet with 30% protein including 15% dairy protein, combined with daily aerobic and resistance exercise, leads to greater loss of fat mass and greater gain of lean mass than diets with lower protein and dairy intake, even when total weight loss is the same.

Causal
Read analysis
Assertion

In overweight premenopausal women undergoing calorie restriction and exercise, a diet with 30% protein increases lean body mass, while a diet with 15% protein results in no gain or a reduction in lean body mass.

Causal
Read analysis
Assertion

People who consume about 1.3 grams of protein per kilogram of body weight and include dairy in their diet while eating fewer calories than they burn gain more lean body mass than those who do not.

Causal
Read analysis
Assertion

In overweight premenopausal women undergoing calorie restriction, higher calcium intake from diet is associated with larger decreases in visceral fat and trunk fat, with dairy sources showing a stronger association than non-dairy sources.

Correlational
Read analysis
Fit Body Science verdict — we translate health studies into clear verdicts backed by peer-reviewed research.

Not medical advice. For informational purposes only. Always consult a qualified healthcare professional before making health decisions.