comparison
Analysis v1
49
Pro
66
Against

When you lift heavy, then quickly lift lighter weights without resting, you can grow muscles just as much as doing regular sets.

Scientific Claim

Drop set training, involving multiple load reductions without rest until momentary failure, produces skeletal muscle hypertrophy equivalent to traditional resistance training with multiple sets.

Original Statement

The drop set arm performed two drop series on the preacher curl and one drop series on the pulldowns. Each drop series had subjects begin performing repetitions with an 8 to 12 rep max load. And the device automatically reduced the load at various points in the set and subjects continued until momentary failure was reached.

Context Details

Domain

exercise

Population

human

Subject

Drop set training with multiple load reductions to failure

Action

produces

Target

skeletal muscle hypertrophy equivalent to traditional resistance training

Intervention Details

Type: exercise
Dosage: Multiple load reductions without rest, starting at 8–12 RM, continuing to failure
Duration: 10 weeks

Evidence from Studies

Supporting (2)

49

This study found that lifting weights with drop sets (going to failure, then lowering the weight and going again) builds muscle just as well as doing multiple full sets with the same weight — but it takes less time.

This study found that doing one heavy set followed by lighter sets without rest (drop sets) built muscle just as well as doing multiple heavy sets the traditional way—even though it took less time.

Contradicting (1)

66

The study found that regular weight training made muscles grow a little more than drop sets, even though drop sets were faster. So, drop sets aren’t just as good for building muscle—they’re slightly worse.