Fly larvae that feed on decomposing human muscle tissue have unusually high levels of a specific nitrogen isotope compared to herbivores and carnivores. If early humans ate these larvae, their own...
Mechanism
Synthesis from 1 study
When meat rots, bacteria remove a lighter form of nitrogen, leaving behind a heavier one. Flies that lay eggs on the rotting meat produce larvae that eat this heavy nitrogen and store it in their bodies. If humans ate those larvae, their bodies would show the same heavy nitrogen signature—even if...
Most probable mechanism
When animal tissue starts to rot, bacteria break it down and release a lighter form of nitrogen into the air, leaving behind a heavier form. Fly larvae eat this rotting tissue and the surrounding gooey fluid, which is now full of the heavier nitrogen. As the larvae grow, they use that heavy nitrogen to build their own bodies, making their tissues much heavier in nitrogen than the original meat. When a human eats these larvae, the heavy nitrogen gets absorbed into their body too, making their isotopic signature look like they ate a lot of meat—even if they didn’t.
Microbial decomposition of muscle tissue preferentially releases volatile compounds containing the lighter nitrogen isotope (14N), such as ammonia and amines, into the environment.
The residual decomposing tissue and surrounding nutrient-rich fluid become progressively enriched in the heavier nitrogen isotope (15N) due to the selective loss of 14N.
Fly larvae ingest the 15N-enriched substrates, including decomposing tissue and decomposition fluid, and assimilate the heavy nitrogen into their proteins during growth and metabolism.
The heavy nitrogen isotope (15N) becomes incorporated into larval biomass at levels far exceeding those of the original tissue, resulting in elevated nitrogen isotope ratios.
When consumed by hominins, the 15N-enriched larval tissues are digested and their nitrogen is incorporated into human tissues, elevating the host's nitrogen isotope signature without requiring high meat consumption.
Evidence from Studies
Supporting (1)
Community contributions welcome
Neanderthals, hypercarnivores, and maggots: Insights from stable nitrogen isotopes
Contradicting (0)
Community contributions welcome
Gold Standard Evidence Needed
According to GRADE and EBM methodology, here is what ideal scientific evidence would look like to definitively prove or disprove this specific claim, ordered from strongest to weakest evidence.