assertion
Analysis v1

Even though people in the past ate more butter and meat, their bad cholesterol was probably higher than ours today—yet they didn’t get heart disease.

Evidence from Studies

Supporting (0)

0

Community contributions welcome

No supporting evidence found

Contradicting (2)

0

Community contributions welcome

This study fed monkeys different fats and checked their blood cholesterol, but it didn’t look at whether they got heart disease or compare them to ancient humans — so it can’t tell us if old people eating butter and meat had healthy hearts despite high cholesterol.

This study says eating saturated fat today doesn’t necessarily cause heart disease, but the claim is about ancient people who ate lots of saturated fat and didn’t get heart disease anyway—so this study doesn’t answer that question.