assertion
Analysis v1
46
Pro
49
Against

Shorter rest between sets works just as well for small muscles like biceps as it does for big muscles like legs.

Scientific Claim

The hypertrophic benefit of longer inter-set rest intervals (>60s) is attenuated or absent in exercises involving smaller muscle groups compared to multi-joint, large-muscle-group movements.

Original Statement

It is possible that with exercises that involve smaller amounts of muscle mass, shorter rest between sets are fine. And we know that some of the evidence we have on drop sets, such as the papers by Frink and Okazzi, just used arm isolation movements.

Context Details

Domain

exercise

Population

human

Subject

Exercises involving smaller muscle groups

Action

exhibit

Target

attenuated or absent hypertrophic benefit from longer inter-set rest intervals (>60s) compared to large-muscle-group movements

Intervention Details

Type: exercise
Dosage: Isolation exercises (e.g., biceps curls) vs. compound exercises
Duration: Not specified

Evidence from Studies

Supporting (1)

46

Longer breaks between sets help you work harder and burn more energy when doing big exercises like leg presses, but not much when doing small ones like chest flies — so the benefit of resting longer is much bigger for big muscle moves.

Contradicting (1)

49

The study only looked at squats, not smaller muscle exercises, so we can't tell if longer rest periods help bigger muscles more than smaller ones.