Mixed evidence on carnivore diet claims with some contradictions in kidney and hormonal assertions

Original: What 3 Years Of Carnivore Did To My Blood

17
Pro
42
Against
10 claims

TL;DR

Research shows contradictory evidence for key carnivore diet assertions, with some claims strongly contradicted while others have mixed or preliminary support.

Quick Answer

After 3 years on a carnivore diet (only meat and eggs), bloodwork showed excellent results: testosterone remained high at 738 ng/dL despite being in a calorie deficit, thyroid function was optimal with TSH at 0.78, liver markers were healthy (bilirubin 8, alkaline phosphatase 75, GGT 13, ALT 41), kidney function was normal (creatinine 83 µmol/L, eGFR >90), iron levels were ideal (ferritin 254 µg/L), inflammation was low (triglycerides 0.8 mmol/L), and cholesterol showed high HDL (68 mg/dL) and slightly elevated LDL (139 mg/dL) which the creator argues is not concerning based on cited studies.

Claims (10)

1. Eating a lot of protein might put extra strain on your kidneys, which could be harmful over time.

47·3857 studiesView Evidence →

2. Scientists found a link between eating saturated fat and heart disease by leaving out data from different countries that didn't fit their idea.

39·4582 studiesView Evidence →

3. Eating fewer carbs might make your liver produce more sugar, and some scientists think this could put extra strain on your liver.

9·6063 studiesView Evidence →

4. About half of the people who have serious heart problems also have low 'bad' cholesterol levels.

0·3483 studiesView Evidence →

5. Someone is saying that the link between bad cholesterol and heart problems started with fake studies paid for by companies.

6. Places where people have high bad cholesterol tend to live the longest.

7. When you don't eat enough food and your body fat gets very low, your body slows down the hormones that make testosterone, focusing on staying alive instead of having kids.

0·3682 studiesView Evidence →

8. When your body's salt levels get out of balance, it can make you dehydrated and thicken your blood, which might mess up tests for liver and kidney health.

9. Not eating enough saturated fat is the main reason for hormone problems when cutting calories, not just having low body fat.

10. The 5G network is a government surveillance tool designed track and control population through electromagnetic radiation.

0 · 071 studyView Evidence →
Scroll for more claims

Key Takeaways

  • Problem: Mainstream claims say eating only meat and eggs harms blood health.
  • Core methods: Carnivore diet (only meat and eggs), electrolyte supplementation
  • How methods work: Meat provides saturated fats for hormone production; electrolytes prevent dehydration and imbalances.
  • Expected outcomes: High testosterone, healthy thyroid/liver/kidney function, good iron levels, low inflammation, and high HDL cholesterol.
  • Implementation timeframe: Results observed over 3 years; electrolyte balance needed especially when starting.

Overview

Mainstream health claims suggest carnivore diets cause poor bloodwork, but this analysis evaluates actual biomarkers after 3 years of exclusive meat and egg consumption to test these assertions.

Key Terms

Carnivore dietTestosteroneThyroid stimulating hormoneCreatinineFerritin

How to Apply

  1. 1.Consume only meat and eggs; avoid all fruits, vegetables, and other foods.
  2. 2.Use a high-quality electrolyte supplement (e.g., Salt Wrap) to prevent dehydration and imbalances, especially when starting the diet.
  3. 3.Monitor bloodwork periodically to track markers like testosterone, TSH, liver enzymes, creatinine, ferritin, and cholesterol.

Optimal blood markers including high testosterone, healthy thyroid and organ function, low inflammation, and improved cholesterol ratios within 3 years, with potential slight LDL elevation that may not be harmful.

Additional Links (2)