assertion
Analysis v1
0
Pro
38
Against

Fasting creates harmful stress in your cells, but methylene blue helps clean it up without stopping your body’s natural adaptation.

Scientific Claim

Methylene blue selectively mitigates excessive oxidative stress during fasting while preserving adaptive hormetic responses.

Original Statement

When you're fasting, you have a high amount of oxidative stress. So, this is where methylene blue could come in play. It's not just going to help you from a potential appetite suppressant side, but it's going to help you out from an overall aspect of just neutralizing some of the additional like stress that might come above and beyond.

Context Details

Domain

pharmacology

Population

human

Subject

methylene blue

Action

selectively mitigates

Target

excessive oxidative stress during fasting

Intervention Details

Type: drug
Dosage: unspecified
Duration: unspecified

Evidence from Studies

Supporting (0)

0
No supporting evidence found

Contradicting (3)

38

This study shows methylene blue can reduce harmful stress in fat tissue around the heart, but it didn’t test fasting or whether the body’s natural healing responses are preserved—so it doesn’t prove the claim.

The study found that methylene blue sometimes makes more harmful molecules (ROS) in heart cells, not less, and it was tested in diabetic rats, not people who are fasting—so it doesn’t support the claim that it helps during fasting without disrupting beneficial stress responses.

This study found that methylene blue hurts fish by increasing harmful stress in their bodies, not helping them like the claim says. It doesn’t support the idea that it protects during fasting.