assertion
Analysis v1
49
Pro
66
Against

Doing more reps near your limit makes up for not resting between sets.

Scientific Claim

The increased number of hard repetitions (within 2–3 reps of failure) in drop set protocols compensates for the absence of inter-set rest, resulting in equivalent hypertrophic outcomes compared to traditional training with longer rest intervals.

Original Statement

In some of the drop set data, the drop set group ends up performing a greater number of hard reps. Perhaps this compensates for having virtually no rest.

Context Details

Domain

exercise

Population

human

Subject

Increased number of hard repetitions in drop set protocols

Action

compensates for

Target

the absence of inter-set rest, resulting in equivalent hypertrophic outcomes

Intervention Details

Type: exercise
Dosage: Increased number of hard repetitions (within 2–3 reps of failure)
Duration: 10 weeks

Evidence from Studies

Supporting (3)

49

Even without resting between sets, people who did drop sets grew their muscles just as much as those who took breaks — because they pushed their muscles harder in each set.

Even without resting between sets, doing multiple hard lifts to failure in drop sets builds muscle just as well as traditional workouts with longer breaks.

This study found that lifting weights with short breaks using drop sets (going lighter after each set) built just as much muscle as lifting with longer breaks — meaning you don’t need to rest long to get big muscles if you push hard each set.

Contradicting (1)

66

Even though the drop set workout was faster and pushed muscles harder, it still didn’t build as much muscle as the regular workout with rest breaks.